Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has openly questioned the impact of Matthijs de Ligt at the club, comparing him to former captain Harry Maguire. Scholes, known for his straightforward analysis, expressed doubts about whether De Ligt is truly an upgrade in United’s defense.
Scholes on New Signings
Scholes believes that any new signing should be an improvement over the current players. In his recent statement, he questioned whether De Ligt has made a noticeable difference since joining the club:
> “When you bring players in, you expect them to be a lot better than who you’ve already got.”
The former United midfielder is clear in his stance that players should bring a significant boost to the squad, especially in key positions like defense.
De Ligt vs Maguire: No Significant Upgrade?
Scholes specifically pointed out the comparison between De Ligt and Maguire, suggesting that the Dutch defender has not been the upgrade many fans and analysts expected. He added:
> “De Ligt has come in for Maguire, let’s say, but there’s no big difference there. Is De Ligt an upgrade over Maguire? No, absolutely not.”
This comparison highlights Scholes’ view that the club’s recent defensive changes have not yielded the desired results, leaving room for debate about the effectiveness of the transfer.
Paul Scholes’ remarks on Matthijs de Ligt and Harry Maguire bring a critical perspective to Manchester United’s current situation. While De Ligt arrived with high expectations, Scholes believes the Dutchman has not outperformed Maguire, raising questions about the club’s recent signings. United fans will be hoping that De Ligt can prove his worth as the season progresses, but Scholes’ comments reflect growing concerns about the state of the defense.